If you happen to be arrested or detained in Emeryville, you’ll likely be transported to an Oakland or County jail. The reasons are that the Emeryville Police Station no longer has a holding facility. They haven’t since shortly after 1982 when a 20-year-old women was burned alive in a cell.
On Halloween evening in 1982 just before midnight, Mercedes Banks was arrested by the Emeryville Police for public intoxication. According to a 1982 SF Examiner Newspaper archive, a patrol officer spotted her walking on traffic lanes at the intersection of Yerba Buena Street & San Pablo Avenue. The officer arrested Banks and transported her to the station on a charge of public drunkenness.
According to the police report, while Banks was being booked at the station, she became argumentative and attacked the matron causing bruises to her legs and the arresting officer. Banks was placed in one of the stations four holding cells “to calm down.” Officers confiscated 13 loose wooden matches they found on her prior to placing her in the cell alone.
At 1:47 a.m., the A/V system used to monitor the cells alerted officers to smoke coming from under Banks’ solid cell door. Two officers responded by attempting to contain the flames with a dry chemical extinguisher, but they were overcome by smoke and unsuccessful. Firefighters arrived shortly after, but Banks had already succumbed to smoke inhalation and burns.
It was later determined that the fire originated from the mattress in Banks’ cell. The source of ignition was originally thought to be a concealed match, but a small disposable lighter was later found near the door. The mattress had been pushed against the cell door before it was set aflame.
“All we can say is that it [the fire] was deliberately set,” said then Sergeant Joe Maltby, who performed the investigation. “We don’t know why.”
Police Lieutenant Dave Reno noted that the monitoring cameras cover the hallway, but not the inside of the cells. Only one of the cells was equipped with a smoke detector, a padded cell next to where Banks’ was being held. Emeryville’s facility, built in 1972, was exempt from new regulations that required each cell to be equipped with its own smoke detector.
A Troubled Past
Mercy was born in the Philippines but grew up in neighboring Berkeley. According to interviews with relatives, alcohol was a recurring problem throughout her youth and she began drinking as early as ten years old. She had been hospitalized throughout her youth for drug treatment and at one point served time in a juvenile hall. She dropped out of high school as a teen and was unemployed at the time of her death.
Banks was living with her boyfriend in Oakland at the time but frequently visited her parents who lived nearby. Police said she bad been arrested in Oakland at least twice for public drunkenness. Her relatives acknowledged other arrests for the same offense. “If she was drinking, she was a handful,” her father conceded. “It would take two cops to handle her.”
“I can Imagine her being drunk. but not to do that to herself,” said Jeanie Mazariegos, the oldest of her three sisters.
Internal Affairs Investigation
An Internal Affairs investigation followed and The City was found to be deficient in their Standards & Training for Corrections (STC). One factor was that only one female officer was on duty to both subdue Banks and perform a proper body search.
Instead of bringing the jail up to these standards and hiring additional personnel, Emeryville opted to contract detention services with Oakland. Oakland in turn closed their Glenn E. Dyer jail for seismic and budgetary reasons in 2004. Emeryville now contracts with North County (Downtown Oakland) and Santa Rita (Dublin).
The incident happened amidst a shakeup within our local government as notorious Police Chief John Lacoste was ousted shortly after. Lacoste resigned in 1983 after being accused of a variety of indiscretions including drinking on the job.
City Loses Lawsuit
A lawsuit for Mercy’s death ensued where the Banks family argued that their daughter’s death was the result of inadequate supervision and the presence of dangerous materials. The City argued that her Death was a suicide and that the fire was the result of a defective, flammable mattress.
The City filed a third-party complaint seeking indemnification from the various parties who were responsible for manufacturing, distributing, and selling the mattress involved in Banks’ death. The third-party defendants in-turn filed a motion to dismiss this complaint.
A six-member jury found that poor supervision and training of jail staff indeed contributed to Mercy’s death. They jury ruled that the Banks family were entitled to $230,000 from the city and $435,000 from Lacoste.
Is Local News essential to you?
If so, consider a one-time or recurring contribution to help support our local journalists.
Whoa I never knew this! That’s horrible but thank you for this informative article that explains our current policies. And happy Halloween!!!
Yeah, I don’t know if you remember during the citizens academy, an officer referencing this story. I always wanted to dig into it and find out what really happened. Really tragic!
Very tragic. She was a sweet person, with issues. I knew her and was hanging out with her the night she died before she went out. The persons comment below mine should be deleted it’s a very rotten thing to say and quite incorrect, and irrelevent and RUDE. I personally don’t drink and I’ve never been in trouble with the law and I know Merci was sweet in spite of her issues.
Thank you for your comment Heidi. The comment has been moderated as it contained no useful information and I regret not deleting it earlier.
First Thank You for the story of my sister, Mercedes Banks. Many years later, because OUR family will NEVER forget .I am the baby sister she played with before she left Pacita Banks jr. It changed the whole dynamics of MY life, of OUR lives.I just want you to know that I read the court depositions, and it’s not anything like the lies Ex-Chief John LaCoste,told the papers. If you know of any other articles please post them.
Hello Pacita, Thanks for finding this story and for your acknowledgment and well-wishes. I hope the story is accurate and fair and I’d love to follow up with you for more detail if there’s an opportunity. Clearly Mr. LaCoste had a reputation of not being an honest person.
In addition to the the included article clipping, I also came across this story:
and this court ruling:
I grew up in Emeryville in the 70’s and 80’s and was completely unaware of this tragedy. As a kid I visited the Emeryville PD on a class field trip and I remember the holding cells. We moved from Emeryville to Oakland on June 01, 1992.
[…] of tragedies eroded the EPD’s already tarnished image including the fiery death of a woman in her jail cell in 1982 as well a former officer who was convicted of raping his […]